INFORMATION WARFARE, ECONOMIC COERCION AND HUMAN RIGHTS: ELECTION INTERFERENCE AND THE SANCTIONS REGIMES ON IRAN AND NORTH KOREA
Keywords:
Information warfare; election interference; economic sanctions; human rights; over-compliance; self-determination; hybrid warfareAbstract
This article examines the human rights and legal implications of information warfare and economic coercion, the two non-kinetic ends of the spectrum of hybrid tactics. Adopting an interpretivist, qualitative multiple-case design, it applies a Hybrid Warfare Continuum and a Legal Response Matrix to three cases: Russian interference in the 2016 United States presidential election, and the sanctions regimes imposed on Iran and North Korea, the latter examined not as hybrid warfare but as the most fully documented instances of the human rights externalities of lawful economic coercion. The analysis confirms that human rights law, rather than International Humanitarian Law, is the primary body of law at these ends of the continuum, but shows that this centrality does not translate into adequate protection. In the information domain the gap is principally doctrinal: although attribution was comparatively well established, the wrongfulness of election interference under international law remained contested, and the response proceeded through domestic measures alone. In the economic domain the gap is principally implementational: formally lawful regimes produced severe civilian harm, through over-compliance by financial intermediaries in Iran and through over-broad design and slow exemptions in North Korea. The North Korean case further shows that multilateral Chapter VII authorization does not secure adequate human rights protection, so that formal legal security and human rights sufficiency do not move together. Five recommendations follow, concerning self-determination, over-compliance, ex ante proportionality assessment, standing monitoring, and safeguards for counter-disinformation measures.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.











